Field Note 02 / Repeated comparison
Two Salinity Transects
How should a comparison change when the sample labels are consistent but the two recording times are not?
- Student
- Caleb Boone · Year 3
- Course
- EST 301 / Estuary Processes Inquiry
- Mentor
- Dr. Luca Moreno
- Source
- Six original simulated teaching records

Question
Caleb selected two original simulated teaching transects with three labelled positions each. The tidy lines on his first chart suggested a simple difference between visits. Reading the record sheets again, he found that the times did not align. The project shifted toward explaining what the two short sequences could support before suggesting why their values differed.
Method and record
The classroom dataset supplies salinity in grams per kilogram, a source identifier, a position label and a time for every entry. Caleb checked that units and ordering were consistent, then kept the two dates as separate series. A notebook page records the teaching source and makes clear that these are invented values, not a report from Reedwater.
TH-TEACH-SAL-01 / Original simulated classroom data
Two sequences, six records.
2 sequences shown. All six source records remain in the table.
| Record | Date | Time / ET | Position | Salinity / g/kg |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A-1 | 2026-10-06 | 09:10 | P1 | 8.2 |
| A-2 | 2026-10-06 | 09:25 | P2 | 10.4 |
| A-3 | 2026-10-06 | 09:40 | P3 | 12.6 |
| B-1 | 2026-10-13 | 11:20 | P1 | 9.1 |
| B-2 | 2026-10-13 | 11:35 | P2 | 10.9 |
| B-3 | 2026-10-13 | 11:50 | P3 | 13.0 |
A times 09:10–09:40 ET; B times 11:20–11:50 ET. Six invented entries; no tidal or ecological cause is established. Chart positions are categorical P1/P2/P3, not distances. Show both dates, unit and observation time ranges. Lines connect supplied values for reading only; intermediate positions were not observed. No tide, weather, flow or repeated-date evidence is supplied. Neither cause nor a long-term trend can be inferred.
Download the six original teaching recordsA revision
An early caption described a rise along the reach as though the whole transect had been observed simultaneously. Caleb replaced that caption with a description of the recorded sequence and added times beside the points. He retained the smooth connecting line only as a reading aid, with a note that unobserved positions were not measured.

What the work shows
The final plate places the small table, comparison chart and a time-range note together. Its limited finding is that the supplied classroom sequences differ at the stated positions. It does not establish a tidal effect, long-term trend or ecological cause. Those would require an appropriate design and additional evidence beyond this six-entry exercise.
Next question
Caleb proposes a better aligned repeat comparison and a record of the contextual conditions relevant to the question. The proposal remains a classroom design for review by course staff, not permission to collect samples or a recommended time to enter a site. A supplied-data alternative can test the same reasoning about comparability.
Read the question before the claim.
The source supplies two short sequences at labelled positions. It includes no tide, weather, flow or repeated-date evidence. The comparison can show the six supplied values; it cannot establish a cause, a long-term trend or a result about the real Reedwater setting.