What should change between two versions of a chart, and what must stay attached to the evidence?
Student
Grace Lin / Year 3
Course
COM 301 / Reader Response Inquiry
Mentor
Dr. Tessa Ward
Source
TH-TEACH-COM-01
Illustrative project scene; exact evidence is published as native text, tables and diagrams below.
Question
Grace began with a small simulated dataset and two readers: a student checking the record and a visitor encountering the question for the first time. The initial visitor version removed nearly every qualification. Her project asked how to simplify the route into an explanation without make the apparent finding broader than the classroom evidence.
Method and record
Both versions use the same original invented values and the same stated observation frame. Grace retained units, source label and date range, then varied vocabulary, annotation and the order of explanation. A classroom reader exercise focused on one task: identify what was compared and state one thing that the chart could not establish.
TH-TEACH-COM-01 / Original simulated teaching sources
One original simulated dataset, two editorial versions
Salinity at three labelled classroom positions
A: October 6, 09:10–09:40 ET. B: October 13, 11:20–11:50 ET. Use the record identifier beside each series.
Solid brick line: A / October 6. Dashed sage line: B / October 13.
Original simulated classroom data, not measurements from a real site. Same values, dates and units in both versions; no causal or long-term claim.
Two short sequences, compared at three places
These six invented teaching values differ at the labelled positions. The records were made for different times in the scenario, so the chart does not show why they differ.
Solid brick line: A / October 6. Dashed sage line: B / October 13.
Original simulated classroom data, not measurements from a real site. Same values, dates and units in both versions; no causal or long-term claim.
A title about improvement implied a judgment that the data did not support. Grace replaced it with a description of the comparison and moved the limits note next to the chart rather than underneath a long text. She also added a short definition for a first-time reader while preserving the more detailed record reference in the student version.
Another stage of the same student’s work. Photographic paper graphics are illustrative, not the exact source.
What the work shows
The final pair demonstrates two reading routes through one bounded teaching comparison. The project does not claim that either design persuaded a public audience or produced a measurable social outcome. Its evidence concerns a small classroom editing exercise, and the displayed source note makes that context visible wherever either chart is reused.
Next question
Grace proposes comparing how readers locate the source note in a printed handout and on a narrow screen. That would test a different communication question and require its own record of method and participants. The project ends with a version checklist so that later edits do not quietly detach the qualification from a useful graphic.